In a closely contested decision for the New Orleans Saints' 2025 Offensive Player of the Year, the debate ultimately centered on quarterback Tyler Shough and wide receiver Chris Olave. Despite Shough's significant contributions in elevating the team's offensive performance after becoming the starter, the majority of staff writers cast their votes for Olave. His impressive resurgence, marked by career-best statistics and consistent reliability, ultimately distinguished him as the preferred choice among the contenders, showcasing his pivotal role in the team's season.
Tyler Shough, stepping into the starting quarterback role in Week 9, brought a transformative impact to the Saints' offense. His leadership was crucial, particularly given the challenges of playing with a roster largely comprised of practice squad players at key positions like wide receiver and running back. Over his nine starts, Shough maintained an average of 250 passing yards per game, achieving a 69% completion rate and directly contributing to 13 scores. His presence notably improved the offense's efficiency on third downs, leading to an average increase of over six points and 55 additional total yards per game. This remarkable turnaround under his guidance highlighted his invaluable contribution to the team's performance.
Conversely, Chris Olave's season was a testament to resilience and exceptional talent. After a previous season marred by concussions, which even led him to consider retirement, Olave made a spectacular comeback. He managed to stay healthy throughout the entire year, significantly enhancing his performance across all major statistical categories to achieve career highs. His consistent presence and output were particularly vital during a season characterized by uncertainties at the quarterback position and broader team challenges. Olave concluded the year with over 1,000 receiving yards, solidifying his status as the team's most dependable and productive offensive player. Several staff writers emphasized that given the limited standout offensive options and his consistent high-level play, Olave was the obvious and most deserving candidate for the award.
The choice between Shough and Olave for the Offensive Player of the Year award underscored two different yet equally crucial aspects of offensive excellence. Shough's impact was measured in the overall uplift of the team's offensive metrics and his ability to perform under challenging circumstances, effectively changing the dynamic of the unit. Olave's case, however, rested on his individual brilliance, remarkable consistency, and his inspiring recovery from past injuries to deliver a career-defining season. His consistent ability to produce, despite various team upheavals, ultimately swayed the voters, recognizing his individual achievement as the most outstanding offensive contribution of the season.